The payment of the retirement pension stops when the pensioner (the person who originally acquired the pension, for example the husband) dies. If the husband dies first, the retirement pension for both ex-partners stops. If there is a so-called survivor’s pension for the surviving ex-spouse (for example, the wife), this benefit will be monthly paid out to the wife from the moment of the husband’s death (no lump-sum). So instead of retirement pension, she will receive survivor’s pension. If the woman dies first, the retirement pension will continue to be paid; the entire payment of retirement pension then reverts back to the man. In the current Dutch pension distribution in case of divorce, the survivor’s pension is actually not distributed. The survivor’s pension is built up to benefit the surviving spouse and in the event of a divorce, it goes entirely to the ex-spouse, according to the Dutch concept.
Survivor’s pension
Within the EPO pension scheme, we see that the Dutch way of allocating survivor’s pension does not seem to work very well. For married couples, the EPO pension scheme provides a survivor’s pension (for the surviving spouse) amounting to 60% of the retirement pension with an absolute minimum of 35% of the employee’s last salary. The EPO pension scheme has a specific scheme for the survivor’s pension. The ex-spouse (for example, the wife) is entitled to a survivor’s pension if:
- both ex-spouses have not remarried and;
- the pensionable ex-spouse (for example, the husband) is still obliged to pay a maintenance obligation to the ex-partner at the time of his death.
The amount of the survivor’s pension will not exceed the amount of the maintenance obligation that the ex-wife received during her ex-husband’s life. During the period that the husband owes maintenance, the wife is entitled to a survivor’s pension in the event of her ex-husband’s death. The chance of death of her ex-husband during this period is fairly small. The question is whether she is also entitled to survivor’s pension if her ex-husband dies after the date of retirement.
In the period after the date of retirement, the man will continue to pay part of his retirement pension to the woman due to the pension equalization. In the first two parts of this triptych, we have described how this works in practice. At the moment it is not clear whether the continued payment of the equalization part of the retirement pension in accordance with the Dutch WVP qualifies as such a maintenance obligation for the EPO pension scheme. After all, this is a necessary condition for a woman to be entitled to survivor’s pension after the death of her ex-husband. If the continued payment of the equalization pension for the EPO does not qualify as a maintenance obligation, the woman will not be entitled to a survivor’s pension for ex-spouses. Unfortunately, we are not aware of any examples from which we can infer how the EPO handles such.
Furthermore, the condition remains that both ex-spouses must have remained unmarried until the time of death of the ex-spouse concerned. However, it remains unclear how this will work if one of the parties, for example, enters into a registered civil partnership.
Possible solution
A possible solution entails the following:
The woman gives up her rights to pension equalization. Instead of the pension equalization, the two ex-spouses agree on lifelong spousal maintenance. The man will pay spousal maintenance to the woman as long as both parties are still alive. The idea is that as a result of this, the woman is dependent on the man for her income but as an ex-spouse she qualifies for a survivor’s pension under the EPO pension scheme. In this way, the woman retains her rights to the survivor’s pension. We note that this agreement offers no guarantee of success. To our knowledge, there is no evidence yet that this construction works. It is also important to consider the tax consequences of such an agreement. Spousal maintenance payments may be treated differently for tax purposes than payments from the obligation to equalize the retirement pension. It is very important to carefully record this in the divorce settlement and to include the necessary amendment provisions if the agreements are no longer appropriate due to any change in circumstances, such as changes in tax law, cohabitation, emigration or changes made to the EPO pension scheme.
If several ex-spouses are entitled to the survivor’s pension, the EPO pension scheme has rules for the division of the survivor’s pension between all of the ex-spouses. This should also be taken into consideration in the event of a divorce.
Taking out a term life insurance policy where the man is the insured party and the woman is the policy holder may also be an option to ensure the woman has income in case of the husband’s death.
About the authors drs. Bas Kortenbach is a self employed pension advisor and tax advisor in The Hague specialized in allocation of pension rights in the event of divorce. Bas Kortenbach is registered with the National Register of Judicial Experts (LRGD) is a board member at De Pensioenorde and a member of the pension specialist group at Register Belastingadviseurs Marjet Groenleer is specialized in international divorces. As a lawyer and mediator, she assists Dutch and foreign expats with their divorce. She publishes and lectures. Marjet is a deputy judge at the Amsterdam Court of Appeal (family law section) and a member of the IAFL (International Academy of Family Lawyers), DIAL (Dutch International Child Abduction Lawyers) and the vFAS.
