The European Patent Office (hereafter: EPO) works by an independent legal system which means that although the EPO has a branch in the Netherlands, in many cases it is not bound by Dutch laws and regulations. For example, the salary of EPO employees is not subject to Dutch income tax and neither are these employees covered by Dutch national insurance schemes. The EPO also has its own pension scheme. How this pension should be divided in the event of a divorce is the subject of this triptych. Part I looks at the retirement pension, with part II providing practical examples. Part III focuses on the survivor’s pension of the ex-spouse.
Retirement pension
Distribution of the retirement pension in the event of a divorce is regulated in the Netherlands by the Dutch Pension Reconciliation Act Applicable to Divorce (Dutch: WVP). The spouse who is entitled to the retirement pension keeps the entitlement to this pension. On divorcing, the ex-spouse is entitled to direct payments from the pension provider of a part of the pension payments upon retirement. This amounts to 50% of the retirement pension payments that were accumulated during the period of the marriage. In a Dutch pension scheme with a Dutch pension provider, the pension provider arranges this split payment of the retirement pension to both of the ex-spouses. The pension provider calculates the retirement pension accrued during the marriage and determines to which pension benefits each ex-partner is duly entitled once the (former) employee retires. If the equalization forms are submitted in time (within 2 years after the registration of the divorce), the Dutch pension provider will pay – from the moment the (former) employee retires – each of the ex-partners directly each month. It is a monthly payment not a payment of a lump sum. It is also possible to make alternative agreements about how the retirement pension is to be distributed. An amendment to the WVP is forthcoming and should come into effect on July 1, 2022. Under this new law, the capital value of a pension must be determined. This value will be divided and each ex-partner will receive their own part of the accrued pension. Each ex-partner will then have her/his own retirement pension. This is called ‘conversion’.
If Dutch matrimonial property law applies, the EPO pension does fall under the WVP, however the pension will not be administered by a Dutch pension provider. The EPO pension provider does not calculate what part of the retirement pension has been accrued during the marriage and neither do they provide any split payment of the pension benefits like Dutch pension providers do. As the EPO pension provider does not carry out the pension distribution, the ex-spouses have to organize this themselves. That means extra care is necessary when settling a divorce.
Points for Attention
- The ex-partner who has built up the retirement pension (e.g., the husband) will receive the entire EPO retirement pension. He has to pay part of this monthly to his ex-partner (e.g., the wife). The ex-partners must determine the amount themselves. The EPO pension provider does not calculate this for them. In order to avoid any future disputes about this, it is advisable to already determine these amounts at the time of the divorce settlement.
- The EPO retirement pension contains several benefit components of which it is not always clear whether they are to fall under the WVP: the household allowance, the allowance for any dependents, tax compensation, adjustment and indexation. Ex-spouses should also arrange these things at the time of the divorce settlement.
- Depending on where the ex-partners live and are liable for tax during their retirement, a tax mismatch may arise. The pension benefits received are likely to be fully taxed as income, whereas the amount paid to the ex-partner is not always fully tax deductible. This can create an extra tax burden for the spouse who has built up the pension.
- It is not the pension provider but for example, the husband who has to pay his ex-wife each month. This means that the ex-wife would be dependent on her ex-husband with all the associated risks that accompany this burden. If her ex-husband is unwilling to pay, this will be a problem for the wife each month. Additionally, if the ex-spouses live in different countries, the wife may have additional issues when trying to enforce these payments.
Solutions
Unfortunately, there is no such thing as an all-encompassing solution that can be used for any divorce and that would eliminate all possible problems that may arise. Assignment of the claim of the husband against his pension provider to the wife (as far as it concerns her part) is sadly not an option. In a case before the court of The Hague in 2018, the wife had requested that the husband be ordered to co-operate in transferring part of his claim against the pension provider to her. However, the court refused to grant this request (Court of The Hague 17 January 2018, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2018:594). The wife thus remained entirely dependent on her ex-husband. With every divorce, it is necessary to consider whether there are possibilities to tackle these potential future problems.
We offer a tailor-made service. It is of great importance for both ex-partners to make clear agreements on the division of the retirement pension and the supplementary benefit entitlements in the event of a divorce. This can prevent a lot of hassle afterwards. In part II of this blog, we show an example of how the numbers may work. This clearly shows where issues (may) arise.
About the authors drs. Bas Kortenbach is a self employed pension advisor and tax advisor in The Hague specialized in allocation of pension rights in the event of divorce. Bas Kortenbach is registered with the National Register of Judicial Experts (LRGD) is a board member at De Pensioenorde and a member of the pension specialist group at Register Belastingadviseurs Marjet Groenleer is specialized in international divorces. As a lawyer and mediator, she assists Dutch and foreign expats with their divorce. She publishes and lectures. Marjet is a deputy judge at the Amsterdam Court of Appeal (family law section) and a member of the IAFL (International Academy of Family Lawyers), DIAL (Dutch International Child Abduction Lawyers) and the vFAS.
