Part II: Tax Benefits, Allowances and Bonuses
In this second part of my three-part series on calculating expat maintenance, I will discuss the financial benefits of being an expat and how these benefits may affect the alimony calculation.
Tax Advantages
Expats working for international organisations are usually exempt from paying income tax. As expats are only obliged to pay a limited internal tax, this increases the ability to pay maintenance. Other expats may be eligible for the so-called ‘30% rule’, resulting in a lower tax burden. The standard calculation rules and software programs that exist in the Netherlands for working out maintenance are therefore not fully applicable, since these are based on the regular Dutch taxpayer. The maintenance calculation may need to be adjusted.
Allowances
Allowances are mainly paid to expatriates working for international organisations such as ICC, ESTEC, EPO, OPCW etc. The monthly income consists of a basic salary plus allowances.
Allowance can come in the shape of many forms, i.e., household, dependency, expatriation, education, hardship and housing allowances. These are the most common forms of allowance. Each of these serves a specific purpose and each has its own eligibility requirement. Organisations such as the UN and ICC work with post-adjustment, a correction made due to the differences that countries may have in the standard of living.
To what extent do allowances affect the need for spousal maintenance?
The starting point for determining spousal maintenance is the need of the entitled party. This need is dependent on the living standard enjoyed during the marriage. Do these allowances form part of the ‘wealth’ experienced during the marriage? Case law on this subject varies widely.
On the one hand, it has been ruled that allowances are a source of income of which the family was accustomed to and by which their pattern of expenditure was arranged. Therefore, the allowances are seen as making up part of the prosperity during the marriage. On the other hand, there is case law that shows a conflicting view. This is particularly the case in situations where the allowances relate to higher costs in a country where the partner receiving the maintenance no longer lives. Allowances related to inconvenience, such as hardship payments, are usually disregarded. It depends on the type of allowance and on where the spouses live as to what extent allowances will be reflected in the need for spousal maintenance.
To what extent do allowances affect the financial capacity of the obligated party?
Allowances cannot be higher than the financial capacity calculated for the obligated party. In most cases, allowances can increase the amount to be paid, unless the said allowances concern compensation for hardship.
Note:
- Some allowances lapse or are scaled back after divorce.
- After divorce, ensure to check the concurrence of the dependency allowance with Dutch child benefit. Avoid doubling up or missing out on one of the two.
Bonuses
Expats working for international organisations, e.g., Shell, are sometimes entitled to a bonus. If the bonus is part of a structural wage component, it is taken into account when determining the needs of the entitled party and the financial capacity of the obligated party. Usually an average bonus over the past 3 years is taken into account when these calculations are made. It is up to the obligated party to effectively argue why it is unreasonable to take a bonus into account when determining his or her financial capability, for example, it is not guaranteed that he or she will receive such a bonus from the company in the future.
Any questions? Feel free to e-mail me at mgroenleer@scg-advocaten.nl or call me on 0031 88-909 4970.
